Letter from my Congresswoman:
Standing With My Constituents Against Obamacare
The Democrats have a 75-seat majority in the House of Representatives. They needed 50 percent of the votes plus one to pass legislation. Even with 75 extra votes, they could not find enough Democrats to pass their government takeover of healthcare.
Speaker Pelosi added sweetheart deals. She twisted arms and threatened Members. Finally, desperate to impose their socialist vision on America, President Obama and Speaker Pelosi decided tragically to resort to an unconstitutional slight of hand where they would "deem" the bill passed without voting on it. It was only the uproar of the American people that prevented it.
After all the arm twisting and backroom deals, Democrats secured just enough votes to pass the Senate's government takeover of healthcare late on Sunday night. I voted against this bill and I wonder, if this bill were truly so great, would these tactics have been necessary?
The simple answer is that this healthcare bill is not what the American people want. It is not what they signed up for. Democrats, Independents, and Republicans alike have stood shoulder-to-shoulder opposing this bill, but sadly, all of us are going to get it anyway.
The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) reports that this bill cuts Medicare by half a trillion dollars, raises taxes, and dramatically expands Medicaid. It increases the cost of health insurance for all Americans, and then it mandates that you buy the coverage. It puts an unelected bureaucrat in control of your healthcare. And if you try to escape any of it, there are 16,500 new IRS enforcers created by this bill just to track you down.
Let me say clearly, I am not one who believes that our healthcare system is just fine the way it is. It's a good system - better than most - but it can and should be improved. There are broken programs and broken policies that must be fixed. But this bill does not do that. It completely ignores important issues like frivolous lawsuits and medical malpractice reform. It ignores the need for increased competition. In short, it does nothing to address the rising cost of healthcare.
So what do I support? I support a step-by-step approach to reform. I support healthcare reform that makes insurance more affordable for everyone. I support making sure that Americans cannot have their coverage dropped simply because they get sick. I support making sure that no American is denied coverage because he or she has a pre-existing condition. And I support eliminating fraud in Medicare so that seniors never have to worry if their coverage will be there.
I am not alone.
The Republican plan, available at www.gop.gov, would reduce the cost of health insurance for all Americans. Reports by CBO show that, when compared with the plan that just passed, the average family would have saved $5,000 under the Republican plan. And the Republican plan would have increased coverage without spending a trillion dollars.
Congress should be focusing on the healthcare plans it already runs; Medicare and Medicaid.
I fully support holding insurance companies accountable, but many of my Democrat colleagues have traded accountability for a belief that government-run healthcare won't need any. Did you know that Medicare already denies twice the percentage of claims as private health insurance?
"Medicare for all" was their rallying cry. But, now that they have gotten their way, more than 200 million Americans will see a greater number of their procedures denied and their healthcare delayed. As someone who suffers from asthma, that scares me. I have personally been denied insurance because of a pre-existing condition. I know how difficult that can be and that is why I support doing away with this loophole.
I also support the elimination of lifetime caps on what an insurance company will pay out if you become sick. If you pay for insurance coverage when you're healthy, it should cover you when you get sick, that's the bottom line.
Allowing individuals to purchase a healthcare plan regardless of the state they live in will increase the number of competitors in the market and will help drive down the cost of insurance. Many of my colleagues on the other side of the aisle have argued that a "public option" is necessary to increase competition and choice. I argue that adding one "public option" pales in comparison to allowing thousands of already available health insurance plans to compete with each other.
The American people have been presented with a false choice: you either accept the Democrat plan or you get nothing. The only person offering you that choice is President Obama. From the beginning, my Republican colleagues and I have offered alternatives that would reduce the cost of healthcare for all Americans without raising taxes, or burying our grandchildren with trillions in added debt.
I voted against Speaker Pelosi's government takeover because the American people deserve a better healthcare system, but more important than that, they deserve a choice. That is what democracy is all about. That is why we need to repeal this bill and draw up a better one.
Thank you,
Ginny Browne-Waite